Stock Market Decline: More Trouble for the Global Economy?

The stock market dropped significantly on Aug. 5, 2024, following a period of high volatility. Concerning economic indicators from the United States (U.S.) and an unexpected interest rate hike by the Bank of Japan were major factors in this collapse. Major world indexes experienced a severe drop, but they recovered within 24 hours. Even with this rapid recovery, the incident may be a hint that the world economy is about to slow down.

The fall started in Japan, when the Nikkei index fell more than 12%, the lowest level since the pandemic, marking the country’s largest decline in 40 years. Black Monday in 1987, when world markets lost trillions of dollars in a few hours, was the only day worse. The effect was felt by other key indexes; the U.S. indexes, such as the Dow Jones Industrial Average, Nasdaq, and S&P 500, were plummeted by 2.6%, 3.4%, and 3% from their July highs respectively, while the Kospi dropped by almost 9%, indicating widespread investor anxiety. The impact was also felt on major European financial markets, such as those in France, Germany, and the United Kingdom.

Several factors could potentially explain why this occurred, and one of the main contributing factors is the carry trade. Investors engage in carry trades by borrowing significant amounts of money at low interest rates and then allocating those funds to countries with higher interest rates. This was exactly the case in Japan, where investors had been borrowing money at at near-zero interest rates for years and investing it in markets such as Australia and the U.S. The crash was triggered when the Bank of Japan unexpectedly raised its interest rates, for the first time since 2007 in March and then again in early August, which led to the strengthening of the Japanese yen due to the winddown of the yen carry trade. This shift means that investors and financial institutions that had been heavily reliant on cheap borrowing were suddenly facing the prospect of losing access to low-cost funds for their future investments which created widespread concern and uncertainty in the market, and caused the sell-off.

Another contributing factor to the stock market decline was the increasing concern among investors about a potential recession, which was amplified by the release of the U.S. job report in July. The report highlighted the ongoing increase in unemployment in the U.S., accompanied by a deceleration in job creation. The unemployment rate rose to 4.3%in July, marking its highest level since October 2021, compared to 4.1% in June of the same year.

Many have been referring to the Sahm Rule as a way to gauge the possibility of a recession. According to this rule, if the three-month moving average of unemployment increases by 0.5% from its lowest point in the previous year, it could indicate an impending economic downturn. This rule does not apply in this case. Although a rising unemployment rate is commonly linked to economic downturns, it is not sufficient evidence to confirm a recession.

A recession is officially declared when a country’s GDP experiences a decrease for two consecutive quarters. Nevertheless, the increasing unemployment rate does indicate a potential slowdown in the economy. There are other multiple indicators of a potential slowdown in the U.S. economy, aside from unemployment. These include an unstable housing sector, rising consumer debt, ongoing weakness in manufacturing (which contracted for a third straight month in June), and a slowdown in payroll growth. In fact, payroll growth has decelerated on a three-month basis to its lowest level since January 2021.

Moreover, there is a concerning indicator to consider – the Cboe Volatility Index has reached its highest levels since the pandemic which suggests that investors are feeling uncertain about the future of the stock market. Volatility spread to other markets, affecting forex and commodities as well where gold futures saw a decline of 0.6%, and Bitcoin went through a turbulent phase, temporarily falling before bouncing back.

These factors combined are contributing to the growing concerns about the state of the global economy and played a role in the recent stock market downturn. Although, the market mostly recovered within 24 hours, this doesn’t indicate that we are completely out of the woods.

The downturn serves as a reminder of how interconnected the world’s financial markets are, and how shifts in one region’s policies or economic indicators can have a significant impact elsewhere. This implies possible slowdowns, heightened market caution, and potential effects on consumer and business confidence globally, among other broader ramifications for the global economy. Although there has been an increase in major indexes, there are still underlying economic concerns.

The global economy is still in a risky shape and faces numerous challenges, such as the COVID-19 pandemic’s after-effects and the Russia-Ukraine War. Growing geopolitical tensions in the Middle East are making the situation more difficult since they have the potential to have serious, far-reaching repercussions if they escalate.

Furthermore, concerns regarding the state of the global economy have grown as a result of China’s economic performance in July. Concerns were raised about the future of the country’s sizable manufacturing sector as exports increased at the weakest rate in three months, falling short of projections. This slowdown in export growth reflects growing fears about China’s dominant status in global trade. Despite the government’s initiatives to boost domestic demand after the pandemic, the second largest economy in the world has had difficulty gaining traction.

Further, China faces additional challenges due to an extended real estate downfall and persistent concerns about job security, which have severely lowered consumer confidence. China’s economy grew by 4.7% in the second quarter, barely meeting forecasts and bolstering calls for more policy measures to be implemented to meet the government’s goal of 5% annual growth.

Given this unstable environment, it is especially alarming to consider the possibility of a slowdown in the largest economy in the world, the U.S., as previously discussed. A worldwide economic slowdown and a drop in GDP could result from a series of negative effects set off by a downturn in the U.S. economy. The Federal Reserve’s forthcoming meeting in September is extremely important because of the vital role the U.S. economy plays in the global economy. The decisions made during this meeting will not only shape the future of the U.S. economy but will also have substantial implications for the global economy. Due to the current economic uncertainties, it is imperative that the Fed carefully considers cutting interest rates as a measure to promote economic growth.

Hence, the state of the Chinese economy thus highlights the vulnerability of the global economy, as does the possible slowing of the U.S. economy. A global economic slowdown would affect trade and investment flows, making it more difficult to recover from the recent disruptions. As both of the major economies face challenges, the likelihood of a wider downturn in the global economy grows. For this reason, the Federal Reserve and other key global policymakers must act quickly to prevent a global economic slowdown.

Finally, the recent downturn in the stock market serves as a reminder of the vulnerability and interdependence of the global economy. Even if markets rebounded swiftly, the underlying issues, such as growing unemployment, unstable investor sentiment, and vulnerabilities in major economies like the U.S. and China, indicate that the global economy is not out of danger and may even be slowing down.

Boesler, M. (2024, July 8). World economy latest: The US economy is showing clear signs of a slowdown. Bloomberg.com. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/newsletters/2024-07-08/world-economy-latest-the-us-economy-is-showing-clear-signs-of-a-slowdown

 
Hakyung Kim, J. M. (2024, August 5). Dow tumbles 1,000 points, S&P 500 posts worst day since 2022 in global market sell-off: Live updates. CNBC. https://www.cnbc.com/2024/08/04/stock-market-today-live-updates.html
 
Lee, Liz, and Ellen Zhang. “China’s Imports Resume Growth but Tamer Exports Raise Outlook Concerns | Reuters.” Reuters, August 7, 2024. https://www.reuters.com/markets/asia/chinas-exports-growth-slows-3-month-low-july-imports-up-solidly-2024-08-07/
 
Narea, N. (2024, August 5). What caused the Global Stock Market Meltdown. Vox. https://www.vox.com/money/365271/stocks-dow-nasdaq-recession-us-economy-fed